Tweet
How do people trust advertising for insurance anymore?
I’ve been thinking about this a lot lately, especially after seeing yet another insurance ad pop up while scrolling. You know the type. Big promises, smiling families, and that vague feeling that something important is being left out. It made me stop and wonder how advertising for insurance is even supposed to build trust these days, when most people already feel unsure or skeptical.
From what I’ve seen, insurance isn’t like other products. You’re not buying shoes or ordering food. You’re buying a promise for something that might happen years later. That alone makes advertising tricky. Most people I talk to don’t dislike insurance itself, but they definitely don’t trust insurance ads right away. I didn’t either.
The main pain point for me was confusion. A lot of ads looked polished, but after watching or reading them, I still didn’t really understand what was being offered. Some focused too much on emotional stories, while others dumped way too much information at once. Either way, I ended up feeling unsure. And when I feel unsure, I don’t take action. I just scroll past.
I also noticed how aggressive some ads felt. Countdown timers, bold claims, and “limited time” language just didn’t sit right with me for something as serious as insurance. If I’m planning for health or my family’s future, pressure tactics actually push me away. It made me question whether the company cared more about getting a click than actually helping people understand their options.
Over time, I started paying attention to the ads that didn’t annoy me. Surprisingly, they were usually the simpler ones. No shouting. No complicated terms. Just clear language that explained one thing at a time. Those ads didn’t try to convince me in five seconds. They felt more like a calm conversation than a pitch.
One thing I personally found helpful was transparency. Ads that openly acknowledged common doubts instantly felt more trustworthy. For example, mentioning that policies can be confusing or that prices vary based on real factors made them feel honest. It felt like the ad understood where I was coming from instead of pretending everything was perfect.
I also realized that consistency matters more than I expected. When an ad’s tone matched the website or article it linked to, I felt more comfortable sticking around. On the other hand, when the ad sounded friendly but the landing page felt cold or salesy, I bounced quickly. That mismatch broke trust instantly.
I spent some time reading discussions and articles just to see how others approached advertising for insurance in a more grounded way. One post that stood out explained things in a straightforward, human way without trying to sell too hard. It talked about why trust matters so much in insurance and how ads can either build or destroy it. If you’re curious, this piece on Advertising for Insurance That Builds Trust and Credibility reflects a lot of the same thoughts I’ve had, especially around clarity and honesty.
What didn’t work for me at all were ads that tried to copy trends from other industries. Flashy visuals and clever slogans might work for entertainment or shopping, but for insurance, they felt out of place. I wasn’t looking to be entertained. I wanted reassurance. I wanted to feel like someone had thought through real-life situations, not just creative ideas.
From my experience, the ads that build trust usually do a few simple things well. They explain who the insurance is for. They say what problem it solves. They avoid exaggeration. And most importantly, they respect the reader’s intelligence. No tricks. No fear tactics. Just calm, useful information.
I’m not saying advertising for insurance is easy. It’s probably one of the hardest things to get right. But as a regular person seeing these ads every day, I can tell when something feels genuine. And when it does, I’m much more likely to read further, research more, and maybe even consider taking the next step later on.
At the end of the day, trust isn’t built in one ad. It’s built over time, through consistency, clarity, and honesty. That’s what I’ve learned just by paying attention as a regular user, not an expert. And honestly, I think more insurance ads could benefit from slowing down and just talking to people like people.
From what I’ve seen, insurance isn’t like other products. You’re not buying shoes or ordering food. You’re buying a promise for something that might happen years later. That alone makes advertising tricky. Most people I talk to don’t dislike insurance itself, but they definitely don’t trust insurance ads right away. I didn’t either.
The main pain point for me was confusion. A lot of ads looked polished, but after watching or reading them, I still didn’t really understand what was being offered. Some focused too much on emotional stories, while others dumped way too much information at once. Either way, I ended up feeling unsure. And when I feel unsure, I don’t take action. I just scroll past.
I also noticed how aggressive some ads felt. Countdown timers, bold claims, and “limited time” language just didn’t sit right with me for something as serious as insurance. If I’m planning for health or my family’s future, pressure tactics actually push me away. It made me question whether the company cared more about getting a click than actually helping people understand their options.
Over time, I started paying attention to the ads that didn’t annoy me. Surprisingly, they were usually the simpler ones. No shouting. No complicated terms. Just clear language that explained one thing at a time. Those ads didn’t try to convince me in five seconds. They felt more like a calm conversation than a pitch.
One thing I personally found helpful was transparency. Ads that openly acknowledged common doubts instantly felt more trustworthy. For example, mentioning that policies can be confusing or that prices vary based on real factors made them feel honest. It felt like the ad understood where I was coming from instead of pretending everything was perfect.
I also realized that consistency matters more than I expected. When an ad’s tone matched the website or article it linked to, I felt more comfortable sticking around. On the other hand, when the ad sounded friendly but the landing page felt cold or salesy, I bounced quickly. That mismatch broke trust instantly.
I spent some time reading discussions and articles just to see how others approached advertising for insurance in a more grounded way. One post that stood out explained things in a straightforward, human way without trying to sell too hard. It talked about why trust matters so much in insurance and how ads can either build or destroy it. If you’re curious, this piece on Advertising for Insurance That Builds Trust and Credibility reflects a lot of the same thoughts I’ve had, especially around clarity and honesty.
What didn’t work for me at all were ads that tried to copy trends from other industries. Flashy visuals and clever slogans might work for entertainment or shopping, but for insurance, they felt out of place. I wasn’t looking to be entertained. I wanted reassurance. I wanted to feel like someone had thought through real-life situations, not just creative ideas.
From my experience, the ads that build trust usually do a few simple things well. They explain who the insurance is for. They say what problem it solves. They avoid exaggeration. And most importantly, they respect the reader’s intelligence. No tricks. No fear tactics. Just calm, useful information.
I’m not saying advertising for insurance is easy. It’s probably one of the hardest things to get right. But as a regular person seeing these ads every day, I can tell when something feels genuine. And when it does, I’m much more likely to read further, research more, and maybe even consider taking the next step later on.
At the end of the day, trust isn’t built in one ad. It’s built over time, through consistency, clarity, and honesty. That’s what I’ve learned just by paying attention as a regular user, not an expert. And honestly, I think more insurance ads could benefit from slowing down and just talking to people like people.
